Carolina Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency serving Clayton and the rest of Johnston County from our office at 500 Benson Rd Ste 112 in Garner, a short drive west on US 70 or I-40. We help Clayton families, landlords and business owners compare auto, home, rental property, life and business insurance from more than one insurance company. Most quotes and policy changes are handled by phone or email, and if you’d like to meet in person, call (919) 234-7868 to schedule an appointment at the Garner office.
Call (919) 234-7868 for an insurance quote in Clayton, NC.
Home insurance for Clayton homeowners
Clayton has grown quickly, from the older homes near downtown and Main Street to newer subdivisions off NC 42, US 70 Business and the Flowers Plantation area. If you’re moving to Clayton from another state or from Raleigh, it’s a good time to look at how your new home should be insured rather than just carrying over what you had.
- Homeowners insurance for the house, detached garages and sheds, your belongings, personal liability and living expenses if a covered loss forces you out.
- New construction: we’ll ask about the builder, square footage and finishes so the dwelling limit reflects what it would cost to rebuild, not the purchase price.
- Homes near the Neuse River or local creeks: standard homeowners policies don’t cover flood, so ask us whether separate flood coverage makes sense even if your lender doesn’t require it.
- Condo, townhome and renters insurance for people who are renting while they decide where to buy.
Auto insurance for Clayton drivers
A lot of Clayton households commute on I-40 and US 70 toward Garner, Raleigh and RTP, often with two or three vehicles on one policy. We review your auto insurance liability limits, uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage, deductibles and discounts, and we can quote motorcycles, boats, RVs and ATVs too. A personal umbrella adds an extra layer of liability protection over your auto and home.
Rental property in Clayton
If you kept your first Clayton house as a rental after moving up, or you’ve bought a property to rent out, it usually needs a different policy than the one you had while living there. We quote rental property insurance for one or two rentals and landlord insurance for larger portfolios. Let us know if the rental is long-term, furnished or short-term.
Business insurance for Clayton and Johnston County
New neighborhoods and new employers in and around Clayton keep contractors, landscapers, cleaning companies, shops and restaurants busy. We help Johnston County businesses put together business insurance that matches the work they really do:
- General liability and contractors general liability, including HVAC, plumbing and electrical contractors.
- A business owner’s policy for offices, retail stores and small service businesses.
- Workers’ compensation, which North Carolina generally requires once a business regularly employs three or more people.
- Commercial auto for work trucks, vans and trailers, and a commercial umbrella when a general contractor or lease asks for higher limits.
- Cyber liability for businesses that take card payments or store customer information.
If a general contractor or property manager asks for a certificate of insurance, call (919) 234-7868 with the certificate holder’s name and address once your policy is in force.
Life insurance
Buying a home in Clayton, starting a family or signing for a business loan are common reasons to look at life insurance. We’ll explain term life versus whole life and help you pick an amount that covers your mortgage and the people who depend on you.
How we work with Clayton clients
- Call or email us. Tell us what you need covered and when it needs to start.
- We compare options. As an independent agency we can quote more than one insurance company and explain the differences in coverage, not just price.
- You choose and we stay with you. We help with changes, certificates and claim questions after the policy starts.
What to have ready for a quote
- Your current declarations pages, if you have them
- For a home: address, year built, square footage, roof age and any updates
- For auto: each driver’s license number and each vehicle’s VIN
- For a business: what you do, annual revenue and payroll, number of employees, vehicles, and any insurance requirements in your contracts or lease
Clayton insurance questions
Do you have an office in Clayton?
No. Our office is in Garner at 500 Benson Rd Ste 112, and in-person meetings there are by appointment. You don’t need to visit to get coverage; quotes, changes, certificates and claim questions can all be handled by phone or email. Call (919) 234-7868 to set up a time if you’d like to meet.
I’m moving to Clayton from out of state. What should I do first?
Call us before you close on the home. Your lender will need proof of homeowners insurance, and you’ll need to register your vehicles in North Carolina and carry NC auto coverage, so it’s easiest to set up home and auto together.
Can I bundle home and auto?
Often, yes. Many insurance companies offer a discount for insuring your home and vehicles together, and we’ll show you bundled and separate options side by side.
What other areas do you serve?
Besides Clayton, we work with families and businesses in Garner, Raleigh, Fuquay-Varina, Holly Springs, Willow Spring, Angier, Benson, Cary and Apex, and throughout North Carolina. See our Fuquay-Varina page or our Garner office page.
Ready to compare insurance options in Clayton? Call Carolina Insurance Group at (919) 234-7868.

